EA's that have not performed

[Poiss Poiss]

Really helpful share. Thank You for Your effort!

 

[Matt]

Thanks for sharing your experiences! There are many crappy EAs, and no matter how you change settings, the strategy or the EA itself will fail.

It is nigh impossible to find a reliable EA that can perform consistently in all market conditions without fail, and that has a proven track record lasting over a year, five years, or longer. It is obviously very difficult to achieve.

 

[Matt]

For Defender EA that have been running since August 2018, there is actually no set file, lot size remains 0.01 (and will do until equity is USD4k), EA trades 24/5 and leverage is 1:500. On a daily basis just check the open trades (but don't do anything). So far, so good.

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/bestrobotsforex/defender/2670708

Defender EA looks like it is working for you.
Please share the EA here so others can test it for themselves.

 

[madgimper]

Anything with the letter I in front of it. I money, I swing, I bar. These EA's are total crap. But people keep buying them no matter how bad they are. The results they use as advertising are done under strict modelling and back testing..

 

[StephenGray]

FXBlue - https://www.fxblue.com/live/
Live accounts:

Broker: Equiti
Note – using EA coders’ MT4 affiliate link
Have withdrawn USD930.
Defender EA
https://www.fxblue.com/users/equitidefender (currently not updating - need to reset)
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/bestrobotsforex/defender/2670708
(Investment: USD1k. Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M1. Lot size: 0.01. Starting leverage 1:500)

Broker: Tradersway
twstepstonepoolSM1
https://www.fxblue.com/users/twstepstonepoolsm1
(Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M5. Starting Lot size: 0.1 (see calculation file for details). Starting leverage 1:500)

Broker: FBS
HamsterLitePoolsm1 – Cent account (divide values by 100)
https://www.fxblue.com/users/hamsterlitepoolsm1
(Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M5. Starting Lot size: 1.23 (see calculation file for details). Starting leverage 1:1000)
Note:
Account was going “pear-shape”. After gaining 55%, eventually lost 6% of original balance.

• Changed to Stepping Stone EA on 20190110
• Changed to ‘new’ Life Changer on 20190114

FBSstepstonepoolSM2 – Cent account (divide values by 100)
https://www.fxblue.com/users/fbsstepstonepoolsm2
(Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M5. Starting Lot size: 2.0 (see calculation file for details). Starting leverage 1:1000)

 

[madgimper]

So what are you saying this is not working for you?

FXBlue - https://www.fxblue.com/live/
Live accounts:

Broker: Equiti
Note – using EA coders’ MT4 affiliate link
Have withdrawn USD930.
Defender EA
https://www.fxblue.com/users/equitidefender (currently not updating - need to reset)
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/bestrobotsforex/defender/2670708
(Investment: USD1k. Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M1. Lot size: 0.01. Starting leverage 1:500)

Broker: Tradersway
twstepstonepoolSM1
https://www.fxblue.com/users/twstepstonepoolsm1
(Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M5. Starting Lot size: 0.1 (see calculation file for details). Starting leverage 1:500)

Broker: FBS
HamsterLitePoolsm1 – Cent account (divide values by 100)
https://www.fxblue.com/users/hamsterlitepoolsm1
(Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M5. Starting Lot size: 1.23 (see calculation file for details). Starting leverage 1:1000)
Note:
Account was going “pear-shape”. After gaining 55%, eventually lost 6% of original balance.

• Changed to Stepping Stone EA on 20190110
• Changed to ‘new’ Life Changer on 20190114

FBSstepstonepoolSM2 – Cent account (divide values by 100)
https://www.fxblue.com/users/fbsstepstonepoolsm2
(Currency pair: EURUSD. Time Frame: M5. Starting Lot size: 2.0 (see calculation file for details). Starting leverage 1:1000)

 

[Matt]

StephenGray, please share the EA files for Defender EA.

 

[pouya ghiaci]

wow , so many EAs to test , thanks guys

 

[StephenGray]

So what are you saying this is not working for you?

Hi,
All my live accounts (4x accounts using 3x different EA's) are profitable

 

[StephenGray]

StephenGray, please share the EA files for Defender EA.

Unfortunately, each EA is coded for your trading account.
If you wish, can share the link that you can open you own trading account. In this manner, you will receive your own EA coded for your trading account. In effect, the coder is protecting his IP.

 

[StephenGray]

wow , so many EAs to test , thanks guys

Pleasure. Most welcome.

 

[StephenGray]

Defender EA referral link: https://www.equiti.com/?link_id=0034795&referral_id=0034795
If you use the link, let me know that can get you a coded EA for your funded MT4 account.

 

[Poiss Poiss]

Schweeeet.
Have you used Defender EA? If so, please share your link to myfxbook or fxblue. Will be interesting to compare results.

No, haven't used it yet. Just found it and tested only for compatibility. Nothing else.

 

[StephenGray]

Oh. OK. Might be a great idea to test for a few months

 

[hakan halil akgul]

whats time frame working ? m1? m5?

For Defender EA that have been running since August 2018, there is actually no set file, lot size remains 0.01 (and will do until equity is USD4k), EA trades 24/5 and leverage is 1:500. On a daily basis just check the open trades (but don't do anything). So far, so good.

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/bestrobotsforex/defender/2670708

 

[StephenGray]

whats time frame working ? m1? m5?

Defender EA (the version that I am using) runs only on M1 and only on EURUSD.

 

[Juraj]

T

Hi,
Herewith MnS OO EA. See attached.

hank

 

[Pepper]

Will have to try those. Thanks for the info

 

[Matt]

whats time frame working ? m1? m5?

Impressive results! Thank you for sharing your performance!

 

[Matt]

Hi Ratel,
Some have crashed account - like PipHiker (live account - will not touch this EA), 2000pipsDaily (live accountS), Cash Generator (live account - was probably due to JPY debacle of 3 January '19), TSR5 / TSR2018 (demo), MnS00 (live), WSAID (demo), XxXBetaGenie (demo), TSR Version 2.9 (demo) and Lin Scalper (demo). They all crashed accounts.

Grid - was impatient

Thank you for sharing your experiences!
I vouch that most (95%) of all EAs FAIL!
Very difficult to find a reliable EA that can be truly "Set-and-Forget".